Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Choosing between St. James’s Club Antigua and Hodges Bay Resort & Spa, an HQ Luxury Resort & Residences? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which resort fits best.
Best for travelers who want a secluded all-inclusive resort on a private peninsula with two distinct beaches, diverse accommodation options, and a relaxed Caribbean atmosphere that welcomes both families and couples.
Better for travelers who prefer a contemporary luxury resort experience with modern design, upscale dining, and a refined atmosphere—typically on a European plan rather than all-inclusive.
If you want a secluded all-inclusive experience on a private peninsula with two beaches, multiple dining options included, and a variety of activities, St. James's Club Antigua is typically the better pick—especially for travelers who value the all-inclusive format, beach variety, and a laid-back Caribbean resort feel.
If your priority is a contemporary luxury experience with modern design and you prefer paying as you go for dining, Hodges Bay Resort & Spa usually comes out ahead—particularly for travelers who want refined aesthetics, upscale culinary experiences, and a more boutique-luxury atmosphere.
Bottom line: choose St. James's Club for all-inclusive value, two beaches, and a private peninsula setting, and choose Hodges Bay for a modern luxury resort with contemporary style and European plan flexibility.
| Category | St. James's Club Antigua | Hodges Bay Resort & Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe |
Secluded all-inclusive resort on a private peninsula with two beaches, a relaxed Caribbean atmosphere, and diverse activities for families and couples alike.
Best for All-Inclusive
|
Contemporary luxury resort with modern design, refined dining, and a boutique-style atmosphere on a European plan.
Best for Modern Luxury
|
| Location | On a private peninsula on Antigua's southeast coast, offering seclusion with two distinct beaches—one calm, one with more wave action. | On Antigua's north coast in the Hodges Bay area, with a beachfront setting and contemporary resort surroundings. |
| Rooms & Suites | A range of accommodation styles from rooms to suites and villas, with options spread across the peninsula's hillside and beachfront areas. | Contemporary suites and residences with modern finishes, clean lines, and a design-forward aesthetic. |
| Dining | Multiple restaurants and bars included in the all-inclusive rate, offering variety without additional charges. | Upscale dining venues with a culinary focus—typically on a European plan where meals are paid separately. |
| Pools & Beach | Multiple pools plus access to two beaches on the peninsula—Mamora Bay for calm swimming and Coco Beach with a livelier shoreline. | Infinity pool with contemporary design and direct beach access in the Hodges Bay area. |
| Activities & Amenities | Tennis courts, water sports, fitness facilities, and children's programs included—strong activity offerings for an all-inclusive. | Spa facilities, fitness center, and a more relaxation-focused amenity set suited to the luxury boutique atmosphere. |
| Price & Value | Best value if you prefer all-inclusive pricing with meals, drinks, and activities bundled together. | Best value if you prefer European plan flexibility and are willing to pay for dining and experiences à la carte. |
Accommodations at St. James's Club Antigua offer variety across the private peninsula, with options ranging from rooms and suites to villas, positioned in hillside or beachfront settings.
St. James's Club is the better pick if you want accommodation variety within an all-inclusive peninsula setting.
Hodges Bay Resort & Spa delivers a contemporary luxury experience with modern suites and residences featuring clean design lines and upscale finishes throughout.
If modern luxury design and a boutique resort atmosphere matter most, Hodges Bay is usually the stronger fit.
Dining at St. James's Club Antigua is included in the all-inclusive rate, with multiple restaurants and bars offering variety without the need to track individual meal costs.
Expect:
Hodges Bay Resort & Spa takes a culinary-forward approach with upscale dining venues—typically on a European plan where meals are charged separately.
If elevated dining and culinary focus matter more than all-inclusive convenience, Hodges Bay is usually the better match.
St. James's Club Antigua stands out with access to two beaches on its private peninsula— Mamora Bay offers calm, protected waters while Coco Beach provides a livelier shoreline.
Hodges Bay Resort & Spa features a contemporary infinity pool with clean design lines and direct access to the Hodges Bay beachfront.
If two beaches and a secluded peninsula appeal to you, St. James's Club wins; if modern pool design matters more, consider Hodges Bay.
Activities at St. James's Club Antigua are a strength of the all-inclusive offering, with tennis courts, water sports, fitness facilities, and children's programs included.
Hodges Bay Resort & Spa focuses on a relaxation-first amenity set with spa facilities, fitness center, and a more tranquil resort pace.
If you want included activities and programs for the whole family, St. James's Club offers more; if spa and relaxation are priorities, Hodges Bay fits better.
St. James's Club Antigua offers the most value when you want all-inclusive pricing with meals, drinks, and activities bundled together on a private peninsula.
Hodges Bay Resort & Spa is the better value if you prefer European plan flexibility and want to pay for experiences à la carte.
Choose St. James's Club if you want meals, drinks, and activities included on a secluded private peninsula with two beaches and a relaxed Caribbean atmosphere.
Hodges Bay is the better pick for modern design, refined dining, and a boutique luxury atmosphere with European plan flexibility.
For families with children or active travelers who want tennis, water sports, and kids' programs included, St. James's Club offers more comprehensive activities.
If you want a spa-focused retreat with modern amenities and a tranquil, design-forward atmosphere, Hodges Bay Resort & Spa is the better match.
Questions? Contact Us!
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for St. James's Club Antigua:
